统计研究 ›› 2020, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (11): 15-29.doi: 10.19343/j.cnki.11-1302/c.2020.11.002

• • 上一篇    下一篇

最低工资对企业长、短期杠杆率的异质性影响

邹静娴 谭小芬 施函青   

  • 出版日期:2020-11-25 发布日期:2020-11-24

The Heterogeneous Effects of Minimum Wage on Firms’ Short and Long Leverage

Zou Jingxian Tan Xiaofen Shi Hanqing   

  • Online:2020-11-25 Published:2020-11-24

摘要: 本文基于2007-2012年工业企业和全国县区级最低工资的匹配数据,探讨最低工资对企业杠杆率的影响,研究发现最低工资上升会对企业的长、短期杠杆率产生截然相反的影响。具体而言,最低工资标准每上升10%,企业长期杠杆率将上升0.42个百分点,而短期杠杆率将下降0.29个百分点。针对最低工资对企业长、短期杠杆率的异质性影响,本文给出了两种机制进行解释———“要素替代”和“盈利预期”效应。就作用渠道而言,“要素替代”效应下,最低工资上升意味着资本相对劳动更为便宜,这会促使企业更多地以资本替代劳动,表现为债务的增加,且主要反映在长期债务上。“盈利预期”效应下,企业生产成本上升会恶化企业盈利预期,使得企业减少投资,同时整体性地收缩债务,这主要对应于短期债务调整。进一步,将企业按照高/ 低劳动密集度以及高/ 低市场竞争度进行划分时,异质性分析结果表明,“要素替代”所导致的长期杠杆率上升只在高劳动密集度企业才成立,而“盈利预期”效应导致的短期杠杆率下降只在高市场竞争度企业才成立。

关键词: 最低工资, 杠杆率, 要素替代, 盈利预期

Abstract: Using the matching data of above-scale industrial enterprise database and national minimum wage at county level from 2007-2012, this paper discusses how minimum wage affects firm leverage. It′s found that the effects of minimum wage improvement on firm′s short and long leverages are heterogenous. In detail,when minimum wage increases by 10%, there will be a 0.42percentage point rise in long leverage while a 0.29percentage point decline in short leverage. To explain such heterogeneity, two mechanisms are suggested:“factor substitution” and “profitability expectation”. Under effect of factor substitution, the rise of minimum wage means capital becomes relatively cheaper than labor, which encourages enterprises to replace labor with capital, shown in the increase in leverage, especially long-term leverage. As for the profitability expectation effect, the rise in production cost will worsen the enterprise′s profitability expectation, leading to a decline in investment and an overall contract in liability, asymmetrically shown in short-term liability. Furthermore, when we separate firms according to high/ low labor intensity and market competition level, the heterogeneous analysis finds that the rise in long-term leverage resulting from factor substitution is only significant for the high-labor intensity firms, and the decline in short-term leverage resulting from profitability expectation is only significant among the firms in highly competitive markets.

Key words: Minimum Wage, Leverage, Factor Substitution, Profitability Expectation