统计研究 ›› 2018, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (3): 52-65.doi: 10.19343/j.cnki.11-1302/c.2018.03.005

• • 上一篇    下一篇

群体分析视角下商业银行对金融体系的风险溢出效应研究

赵树然等   

  • 出版日期:2018-03-25 发布日期:2018-03-25

Analysis on Risk Spillover Effects of Commercial Banks on Financial System from a Group Perspective

Zhao Shuran et al.   

  • Online:2018-03-25 Published:2018-03-25

摘要: 本文基于异质市场假说和高频数据,利用高频数据采样频率高及富含波动信息的特点,构造多银行和系统间多元联合分布过程,并将银行间的动态联系纳入考虑,构建了蕴含丰富经济意义、形式灵活的高频动态多条件CoVaR模型及基于此的群体性系统性风险贡献指标。从群体分析视角出发,研究了不同商业银行群体对金融体系的风险溢出效应。结果显示:就系统性风险贡献度而言,该模型准确刻画了近年不同时期下我国三类商业银行系统性风险贡献度的时变特征,其表现为在次贷危机及欧债危机、我国“钱荒”时期及股票市场异常动荡时期,由于风险的传染性等特征导致三类商业银行的系统性风险贡献度均有所上升,而在其他时期则相对平稳;就单个银行对系统的风险溢出影响而言,工商银行的风险溢出比率最大,与其庞大的资产规模以及在金融体系中的重要地位与作用密不可分;当分析同类型银行群体的风险冲击时,国有商行类的系统性风险溢出比率值最高,其次为股份制商行类,该两类的溢出比率相差无几,且均远大于城商行类,表明股份制商行对金融系统的风险溢出影响不可小觑;当剖析不同类型银行群体时,此模型同样适用。本文所构模型能够实现多个银行对金融系统极端风险贡献的度量,可为监管部门的分类监管及有限能力下银行救助顺序的确定提供一定参考依据。

关键词: 系统性风险, 多条件CoVaR, 高频数据, HAR-CAW模型

Abstract: Based on heterogeneous market hypothesis and high frequency data, taking advantage of the characteristics that the high frequency data is not only rich in volatile information ,but also with higher sampling frequency, this essay construct multivariate joint distribution between banks and system process and taking the dynamic contact between banks into account, in this essay, a high-frequency multi-CoVaR model with rich economic significance and flexible forms is constructed, in addition, we propose a group spillover effects index to capture the systemic importance of each group, there are analysis on risk spillover effects of commercial banks on financial system from a group perspective. The empirical results of listed commercial banks in China show that: in terms of systemic risk contribution, the model accurately characterizes the time-varying characteristics of the risk contributions of three types of banks in China this years, for example, during the times of the subprime crisis, the European debt crisis, "money shortage" period in our country and abnormal turbulent times of our country stock market, due to the infectious features of risk, these three kinds of commercial banks' contribution of systemic risk increased, and at other times are relatively stable; in terms of the spill-over effects to system, Industrial and Commercial Bank of China shows the largest, which is closely related to its huge asset size and its importance in the financial system. When analyzing the risk impact of banking groups with same types, the state-owned firms shows the largest, followed by the joint-stock commercial banks. The systemic risk contribution rate of this two groups are almost the same, both are much larger than the city commercial banks. It shows that the risk spillover effect of joint-stock commercial banks on the financial system should not be underestimated; this model is also applicable when analyzing different types of banking groups. The model built in this essay can achieve measuring the spillover effects of a group of banks, it can provided reference to financial supervisory departments for classified regulation and assistance order with limited abilities.

Key words: Systemic Risk, Multi-CoVaR, High-Frequency Data, HAR-CAW Model