统计研究 ›› 2023, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (2): 101-116.doi: 10.19343/j.cnki.11–1302/c.2023.02.008

• • 上一篇    下一篇

房地产市场波动、宏观审慎政策有效性与双支柱调控

江振龙   

  • 出版日期:2023-02-25 发布日期:2023-02-25

Real Estate Market Fluctuations, Effectiveness of Macroprudential Policy and Two-Pillar Policy Regulation

Jiang Zhenlong   

  • Online:2023-02-25 Published:2023-02-25

摘要: 房地产市场波动对经济波动具有显著影响,促进房地产市场平稳健康发展对经济高质量发展具有重要意义。本文将家庭购房按揭贷款和房地产开发商抵押贷款嵌入带有金融中介的动态随机一般均衡(DSGE)模型,分析房地产市场波动对宏观经济的影响和传导机制,讨论宏观审慎政策调控房地产市场的有效性并评估双支柱调控效果。研究发现:住房偏好冲击驱动房价上涨,拉升银行杠杆,扩张信贷,积累金融风险;一旦风险显现,来自银行内部的金融冲击通过恶化银行资产负债表,收紧信贷约束,造成经济波动。本文选取两类住房金融监管工具进行逆周期宏观审慎政策实验,结果表明:最优贷款价值比政策和最优资本充足率政策对房价均可积极调控,但对信贷调控力度存在差异;宏观审慎政策对不同家庭福利存在取舍,社会福利通过卡尔多?希克斯效率增进。基于拓展的政策前沿曲线分析可知,宏观审慎政策通过降低顺周期信贷波动减轻了房地产市场波动对宏观经济的冲击,并与货币政策形成合力,提高了经济和金融稳定性。本文为厘清房地产市场波动的传导机制、研判宏观审慎政策调控房地产市场的有效性以及健全双支柱调控框架提供了政策启示。

关键词: 房地产市场波动, 宏观审慎政策, 双支柱调控, 经济和金融稳定

Abstract: This paper embeds housing mortgage loans and real estate producer mortgage loans into a DSGE model with financial intermediaries to examine the impact of real estate fluctuations on the macroeconomy, and evaluate the effectiveness of macroprudential policies in regulating the real estate and the effect of two-pillar regulation. We find that housing demand shocks drive up housing prices, which in turn increases bank leverage, expands credit, and accumulates financial risks. Once the risks emerge, financial shock from the bank will worsen the bank’s balance sheet, tighten credit constraints, causing macroeconomic fluctuations. In order to deal with the impact of real estate fluctuations on the macroeconomy, two housing financial supervision tools, loan-to-value (LTV) and capital adequacy ratio, are selected to conduct countercyclical macroprudential policy experiments. The results show that the optimal LTV and the optimal capital adequacy ratio can both actively regulate house prices, but there are differences in their response to credit. Macroprudential policies have trade-offs for different family welfare, and social welfare improves through Kaldor-Hicks efficiency. Based on the extended policy frontier curve analysis, macroprudential policy reduces the impact of real estate fluctuations on the macro economy by decreasing procyclical credit market fluctuations, and coordinates monetary policy that aims at the aggregate economy to enhance economic and financial stability. This study provides policy implications for clarifying the impact mechanism of real estate fluctuations on the macroeconomy, as well as the effectiveness of macroprudential policy to regulate real estate and improve the twp-pillar regulation framework.

Key words: Real Estate Market Fluctuations, Macroprudential Policy, Two-Pillar Policy Regulation, Economic and Financial Stability