统计研究 ›› 2022, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (9): 119-127.doi: 10.19343/j.cnki.11–1302/c.2022.09.009

• • 上一篇    下一篇

当代经济统计学的深化、提升与拓展——邱东教授《经济测度逻辑挖掘:困难与原则》述评

罗良清 平卫英   

  • 出版日期:2022-09-25 发布日期:2022-09-25

The Deepening, Improvement and Expansion of Contemporary Economic Statistics: A Review of Explore the Logic of Economic Measurement: Difficulties and Principles by Professor Qiu Dong

Luo Liangqing Ping Weiying   

  • Online:2022-09-25 Published:2022-09-25

摘要: 《经济测度逻辑挖掘:困难与原则》是邱东教授“当代经济统计学批判系列”的第一册,主要针对“SSF经济测度报告”存在的问题展开述评,体现了该书作者对当代经济统计学的深层次思考。本文以国内生产总值(GDP)的“基本功能”之辩作为开篇,指出测度“可行性”对其“必要性”的动态制约,探讨了GDP功能与核算体系的潜在挑战;以政府产出测度为例,区分了经济科学中的“理论概念”与相应的“测度概念”,点出经济指标从来都是隐含着经济学立场的;基于邱东教授提出的GDP统计隐含四大测度困局,梳理宏观经济指标的测度原则及其之间的关系;围绕生活质量测度的可行性、必要性以及可持续发展测度的观念前提作出反思,指出其中存在的可加性疑点,并系统剖析了目前流行的不同类别方法的测度机理;最后阐述了邱东教授对经济统计学学科格局的观点,指出“超越GDP”的宏大目标并没有实现,经济统计学学科还需要深化、提升和拓展,经济统计学大有可为。

关键词: 经济测度, 可加性疑点, 经济统计学学科格局, 超越GDP

Abstract: Explore the Logic of Economic Measurement: Difficulties and Principles is the first volume of Critical Series of Contemporary Economic Statistics by Professor Qiu Dong. It mainly reviews the problems existing in SSF Economic Measurement Report, reflecting the author?s deep thinking on contemporary economic statistics. This paper begins with the debate on the “basic function” of GDP, points out the dynamic restriction of measuring “feasibility” to its “necessity”, and discusses the potential challenge of GDP function and accounting system. Taking the measurement of government output as an example, this paper distinguishes the “theoretical concept” and the corresponding “measurement concept” in economic science, and points out that economic indicators always imply economic standpoint. Based on the four measurement dilemmas of GDP statistics proposed by Professor Qiu Dong, the measurement principles of macroeconomic indicators and their relations are sorted out. Then it reflects on the feasibility and necessity of life quality measurement and the conceptual premise of sustainable development measurement, points out the existing doubts about additivity, and systematically analyzes the measurement mechanism of different types of currently popular methods. Finally, this paper expounds Professor Qiu Dong?s views on the discipline pattern of economic statistics, pointing out that the grand goal of “beyond GDP” has not been realized, and the discipline of economic statistics still needs to be deepened, improved and expanded, and there is much potential in economic statistics.

Key words: Economic Measurement, Doubts about Additivity, Discipline Pattern of Economic Statistics, Beyond GDP