统计研究 ›› 2022, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (8): 115-128.doi: 10.19343/j.cnki.11–1302/c.2022.08.008

• • 上一篇    下一篇

合成控制法中的安慰剂检验改进研究——基于准标准化转换的统计推断

连玉君 李 鑫   

  • 出版日期:2022-08-25 发布日期:2022-08-25

Improved Placebo Test for Synthetic Control Method: Inference with Quasi-standardized Transformation

Lian Yujun Li Xin   

  • Online:2022-08-25 Published:2022-08-25

摘要: 合成控制法的统计推断主要基于以置换检验(permutation test)为基本思想的安慰剂检验。为了应对干预前拟合欠佳对统计推断的影响,前期文献往往需要人为删除部分拟合欠佳的样本,存在较强的主观性。本文通过准标准化转换来惩罚安慰剂检验过程中的噪音成分,提升干预后时段政策效果的可比性,以在不删除观察值的情况下实施安慰剂检验。研究表明,准标准化转换具有如下优势:首先,能有效提升干预前控制组与实验组的可比性,减少噪音成分对检验结果的影响,蒙特卡洛模拟分析证实了该结论的稳健性;其次,基于转换样本的安慰剂检验无需人为删除拟合欠佳的控制组样本,使检验结果更为客观;最后,以转换样本为基础,可以使用Bootstrap法构造各个时点上政策效果的置信区间,从而使合成控制法的统计推断框架与传统统计推断保持一致。

关键词: 合成控制法, 安慰剂检验, 自抽样, 置信区间

Abstract: The inference of the synthetic control method mainly relies on the “placebo test”, which is based on the permutation test. However, because of the poor fitting in the pre-intervention period which results in ineffective inference, previous studies choose to subjectively delete the control units with poor pre-intervention fitting. This article introduces a process of quasi-standardized transformation to eliminate the noise component in the placebo test in order to improve the comparability of treatment effects in the post-intervention period and to ensure that we can implement placebo tests without subjectively deleting any units. We find that our method has several advantages: Firstly, it can effectively improve the comparability of control units and treated unit during the pre-intervention period, reducing the influence of noise components on the test result. Our Monte Carlo simulation results further proves the robustness of this conclusion. Secondly, it avoids the manual deletion of the poor fitting control units so that the inference can be more objective. Finally, we can use the data, transformed by the quasi-standardized processing, and the bootstrap method to construct the confidence interval of the treatment effects, thereby ensuring that our statistical inference framework for the synthetic control method can be consistent with traditional inference methods.

Key words: Synthetic Control Method, Placebo Test, Bootstrap, Confidence Interval